WAAS Up?
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
The Government Accountability Office, a Federal watchdog agency, reported on May 7th that the Global Positioning System of satellites used for navigation and many other business and scientific purposes as well as for proving that your teenage son was actually driving down the Interstate at 100 miles-per-hour last Thursday night when he claimed to be bowling, well that satellite system is in danger of becoming unusable because satellites are not being replaced quickly enough by the U.S. Air Force.
Only it isn’t true.
Right now on Google News you can find more than 400 stories all saying the same thing with varying degrees of alarm. The Air Force is three years late in launching a new generation of GPS satellites. The replacement program is over-budget by more than $700 million. The whole mess has been incompetently run and ought to be fixed. All this is true. What isn’t true is that it matters very much to the real world operation of the GPS system or its users.
The GPS system has 31 satellites in orbit right now, the oldest of which has been operating since 1990. For the system to work perfectly it must have 24 or more satellites functioning. The GAO says it is only 80 percent certain that the Air Force can maintain full coverage before replacement satellites can be launched. This lack of confidence is not based strictly on the idea that eight or more satellites will go dark over the next couple years, but that some undetermined number of satellites will go dark, the Air Force will make no progress in replacing them, and that the remaining satellites will be unable, for some reason, to be moved into new positions, filling gaps in coverage. That’s quite a combination of improbable events and makes me very suspicious of the 80 percent number.
For the GPS system to work requires that the receiver in your car, airplane or iPhone be able to simultaneously track at least three satellites (four if you require altitude information). If your receiver can show the satellites it is tracking (many can) you’ll see the number in sight is usually five to seven satellites with the rest being over the horizon and out of view.
If your GPS equipment was purchased in the last couple years it probably makes use of the Wide Area Augmentation System (WAAS), which is a system of ground stations and two geosynchronous satellites that help your receiver correct for ionospheric variations that can slightly degrade GPS performance. Without WAAS your GPS is only accurate to 7.6 meters. With WAAS accuracy is about one meter. The reason we care about this is because GPS is used now to land airplanes and the difference between 3.8 meters above the runway and 3.8 meters below the runway could ruin your whole day.
In addition to improving GPS accuracy over North America (and just North America — there are different systems for Europe and Japan), WAAS also effectively adds two virtual satellites to the GPS constellation. These are the two geosynchronous reporting satellites, which for ease of use in the system are treated by receivers like regular GPS satellites except they for some reason don’t seem to move in the sky. For WAAS-enabled GPS receivers, then, it is possible to maintain acceptable accuracy with only ONE (not three) of the regular GPS satellites in view.
The chances of the GPS system going down are very remote — FAR lower than the 20 percent suggested by the GAO. That’s because the GAO ignored completely in its analysis the implications of WAAS.
So what’s going on here? Why is this even a story?
The Air Force is late and over budget and the GAO wants to make a point of that. The best way to make that point is by putting the technical story in the worst possible light, which the GAO has done to an extreme that I think is excessive. This is just political infighting.
What’s worse, though, are those 400+ news stories that miss the point entirely. Where is a professional and questioning press? It looks to me like 400+ media outlets rewrote the GAO press release and left it at that, giving-in to the fear-mongering that has become the way government policy is promoted these days.
Some stories quoted experts saying a failure isn’t likely. Some stories said the GAO likely has a non-technical agenda. But I couldn’t find any stories that put the whole thing together and questioned whether there was any news value at all.
We need smarter, better-informed, and less gullible reporters. THAT’s the story.
Interestingly, GPS coordinates are being gathered by the census bureau – to help deliver the mail or something I guess.
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5590541
Bob, that is the sole reason why many people read your rants. They are both informative and provocative.
Look at this….
Sweet site dude, check out mine when you get a min……
Bob this almost makes up for your Bowling for Dollars article. Almost.
Thanks you. Concise, very factual, and yet another example of the new standards of American reporting. Yours: excellent and checkable. The rest: abysmal, and the reason America has little credibility in the world today.
Thanks again.
What are your thoughts on eLoran providing additional redundancy and eliminating some of the GPS line of sight issues? Is the eLoran debate similar to this?
[...] been curious myself since this comment showed up on the blog linking to Cringely’s article on WAAS. I don’t think there are many issues in using it close to shore as I know a number of DP systems [...]
Interesting blog as for me. It would be great to read something more concerning this theme.
Kudos from one braniac to another.
Hi there, I discovered your blog via Google even though looking for initial aid for a heart attack and your post looks really exciting for me.
I use google maps query to your door with a few trees. This is a joke. But a serious infringement of personal privacy.
I think that civilian satellites private information should not be arbitrary on the Internet, for human inquiry.
None but a mule denies his family.
GPS is very useful specially the ones that are put on the Car dashboard. it can really help you drive on unfamiliar places.–`
Interesting topic. I plan to build my first blog, based on similar topics to those from here. Thanks for the work that you do for this blog! Cam Girls
Hi all, im really happy
i just got my new IPhone 4G for FREE lol!. I didn’t think it would work but it pulled through. I followed the steps on http://freeiphone4g4u.blogspot.com and i just thought ide share it!
Among the most used CMS programs today are WordPress, Mambo, Joomla, and Drupal, all of which are free as open source applications. Among the proprietary applications there are also a number of options, with offerings from big companies including Microsoft and Oracle. One factor many organizations overlook is the cost-benefit comparison of Open Source software versus proprietary, works out of the box programs.
I am sure your RSS feed option is here somewhere and its just me being blind, but where is it lol
Thanks for taking the time to write that, I found it very detailed. If you get a chance you should check my site as well. I hope you have a nice day!
cheap VPS
I retain listening to genuine news speak about getting free online grant applications so I have been looking around for real best site to get one.
Great to have this comment box functioning again.
Quite Lovely post. Never tot it was dis simple afterall. I’d spent a good deal of my time lookin for some1 to explain dis topic clearly
GPS are very useful on day to day travel if you do not want to get lost;..
Hi, sorry for enquiring this inquiry here, but I am not ableto find a contact form or something so I thought I leave my question here. I run a blogengine blog but I am getting large amounts of spam. I see u use wordpress, is it straightforward to regulate spam with wordpress or doesn’t it make any difference? I hope you will respond to my comment or maybe send me an email with your answer if you don’t want to approve the comment. Best regards, Annie Green Investment
Very interesting read. I am a blogger myself and of lately I have found that managing my own site has been a pain in the neck, especially for those technical jargon i have to solve. I recently found a new blogging community where you can just setup a blog and forget about it. Check it out, might be useful later
Hi Johnson. So fare i can see, Toner has answered your question. I don’t see any sense.
: )!!!
could be Audi sections and also labor really alot even more high cost than lots of Other cars? i just got an 1997 audi a6 (a gift – i didn’t buy it) but this wants the job. A few probably are telling me i have on gotten on over my head do to this will be ever so much more costly To keep this automobile build up than Most various other autos. how true is this
satellite receivers that are made in china are sometimes does not follow frequency standards,.,
bwfimzpfxljhfkprhp, 1800 mattress, WcCdqCbgmGGFySlykPOH. kbrpkhtzdpvlaqhzgb, gloria vanderbilt jeans, lpiOVJTETFAGsrpUEPYW.
Every time I stumble upon a really good article I do three things:1.Forward it to all the relevant friends.2.keep it in all my best social bookmarking sites.3.Be sure to come back to the same website where I first read the article.After reading this article I am really concidering doing all 3.
Took me awhile to read all the comments, but I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be very useful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here! It’s always nice when you can not only be informed, but also engaged! I’m sure you had fun writing this article.
some satellite receivers are not very good in tracking and receiving satellite signals”";
i liked her hair…
)
can i get the bandit in the uk yet
my GPs unit is made by Hewlett Packard and they seem to make very sturdy gps units*~.
great thanks man…
thanks for help! I will try.
This is a smart weblog. I mean it. You have so much knowledge about this issue, and so much passion. You also know how to make people rally behind it, obviously from the responses. Youve got a style right here thats not too fancy, but makes a statement as large as what you’re saying. Great job, indeed.
This blog appears to recieve a great deal of visitors. How do you advertise it? It offers a nice unique spin on things. I guess having something authentic or substantial to give info on is the most important thing.
good (article|information) thanks
[...] who may well have a good point, so let’s reconsider for a moment the security of GPS.I wrote more than a year ago that a Government Accountability Office report was overblown, claiming a 20 percent chance of the [...]
pronounced register you’ve gain
Excellent piece of writing and actually helps with learning the subject matter better.
I will tell fairly … the first time has come on your site on purpose “clever spam”.
But to write that that close on a theme it is necessary to read. Has started to read – it was pleasant, Has subscribed and with pleasure I read. Very to be pleasant your site – interesting The maintenance, pleasant design for reading … 
I will tell fairly … the first time has come on your site on purpose “clever spam”.
But to write that that close on a theme it is necessary to read. Has started to read – it was pleasant, Has subscribed and with pleasure I read. Very to be pleasant your site – interesting The maintenance, pleasant design for reading … 
Oh,nice article. Good informations..
Oh,nice article. Good informations..
I will tell fairly … the first time has come on your site on purpose “clever spam”.
But to write that that close on a theme it is necessary to read. Has started to read – it was pleasant, Has subscribed and with pleasure I read. Very to be pleasant your site – interesting The maintenance, pleasant design for reading … 
the satellite receiver that we bought at best buy is great, we always use it whenever we are out camping “