Microsoft Has PMS
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Program Manager Syndrome, that is.
A few days ago I called for Microsoft to slash not 5,000 jobs but 50,000 to make the company lean and focused once more. Readers responded by asking which 50,000 Microsoft heads I’d like to see cut off? Wow, what a great question! So great, in fact, that it inspired this column and probably the one after. Because it’s not that simple to just fire half a company. It’s remarkably easy, in fact, to fire the WRONG half.
Restructuring Microsoft has to have a point beyond simply improving profitability, which was pretty darned good to start with. It requires first identifying the systemic problems inside the company that ought to be addressed by thoughtful, if brutal, change.
But people don’t gchange. That kid you knew in high school who was a weasel-rat, well he’s probably a fat and balding weasel-rat today. People are sometimes changed by life- or career-threatening experiences, but generally not even then, which is why organizations that try to change hardly ever succeed.
So you have to cut deep – very deep – to make change stick. One approach to show management is serious about change is to attack the big identity aspects of the concern like its name, where it is based, and who is running the show. Remember Boeing moved its corporate headquarters to Chicago in an attempt to show the world it was a different company. ValuJet merged with a smaller company and changed its name to AirTran. If Microsoft is going to successfully change it will have to make similar moves, at least for some divisions.
Current top management, of course, should go.
Microsoft has several systemic problems holding it back. Like many big, proud, older, successful-if-fading-somewhat companies, Microsoft’s problems are seen by some as the reasons for the company’s past success, which they may well be. It’s just that Microsoft has outgrown those old ways of doing things (or the market has) only they haven’t figured that out yet.
Ignoring completely the company’s anti-trust issues, Microsoft’s primary failing is technical arrogance. Some of this is native and some is a vestige of Redmond’s long association with IBM. Taking the IBM connection first, let’s look at something current Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer said in my 1996 PBS documentary, Triumph of the Nerds:
“In IBM there’s a religion in software that says you have to count KLOCs (pronounced KAY-lock), and a KLOC is a thousand lines of code. How big a project is it? Oh, it’s sort of a 10 KLOC project. This is a 20 KLOCer. And this is 5O KLOCs. And IBM wanted to sort of make it the religion about how we got paid. How much money we made off OS/2, how much they did. How many KLOCs did you do? And we kept trying to convince them – hey, if we have – a developer’s got a good idea and he can get something done in 4 KLOCs instead of 20K-LOCs, should we make less money? Because he’s made something smaller and faster, less KLOCs. KLOCs, KLOCs, that’s the methodology. Ugh!”
While Microsoft learned a lot from IBM, this whole KLOC-orientation and associated ass-backward reward scheme repulsed them because it led to bloated code. So just like a child who grows to ultimately emulate or rebel against parental examples, Microsoft shunned the KLOC and embraced the power of tight code. And though it might surprise you from looking at their current product lines, they still do.
The way a company that prides itself on tight code can build something as floppy (in every sense) as Windows Vista is because Vista is simply too big for any one Microsoft executive or engineer to understand in detail. So they embrace the idea that piling lots of chunks of tight code somehow won’t turn into a huge steaming mass of not-very-tight product. But it does.
But wait, there’s more! Somehow this mistaking fat for muscle became institutionalized at Microsoft through a unique group of people called Program Managers or PMs. This is a Microsoft invention intended to make their products more useful and elegant, yet in practice the PMs do just the opposite.
Program Managers at Microsoft are the advocates for software usability. They link (or are supposed to link) to the rest of the company development, usability and testing. They write specs and try to optimize the user experience, though with only limited success.
The bloated development, test, and PM teams across the company are a sign of Microsoft’s obsession with technology and all things technical. There aren’t nearly enough usability engineers, designers, writers, editors, and other people who worry about how usable the software actually is. In other words, like the people who run the feature teams at Apple.
A Microsoft designer once said that the biggest difference between Apple and Microsoft was that at Apple designers usually owned the product features, while at Microsoft, PMs always own the features. And most of the PMs at Microsoft are highly technical, often with computer science degrees. This is considered a good thing, by the way, but it isn’t good at all. It means the PMs tend to lean in favor of the developers just as management leans in favor of the developers, too. So in most cases where usability goes head-to-head with development, usability loses. And so do users.
The answer for Microsoft is not to blindly copy Apple because Microsoft will never BE Apple and will never have a Steve Jobs as boss. The answer is to adopt a similar product design philosophy to Apple’s with the focus squarely on usability.
This will not happen EVER with the present culture at Microsoft.
The first head of usability at Microsoft was a woman named Mary Dieli whom I met at Apple in the early 1980s when she was an intern there. Mary, who went on to get her PhD at Carnegie Mellon, ran usability for Adobe Systems and then was lured to Microsoft around the time of Windows 3.0. We used to talk, she and I, about her frustration at Microsoft and how difficult it was to be the champion of something that was considered non-technical, even effete, like usability. Mary could never break into the boys club that runs Microsoft. It’s not just that she was a woman, though, it’s that her field got only lip service, not respect.
At Microsoft the PMs and development managers have the power to control product features, not the usability researchers and designers, who are overworked and without real authority. Microsoft needs to somehow shift its corporate culture away from an obsessive focus on technology and engineering toward creating software that’s much more user-friendly. Until it does this, the company will continue to be slammed for its products.
Next time we’ll consider exactly what sort of tough love will be required to make Microsoft in the 21st century the kind of success it was in the 20th.
This information is bit incomplete, I must say that the homework was done really good, but the problem came when you tried to assemble this information and present it. No doubt you did your best and I appreciate the fact that this will help as well, you should read other posts as well to make your posting really to the point and really understandable. I will PM you some of the threads about this topic so that the next time you visit the forum and post something really informative like this, it will be more effective and helpful to all.
Any tips for me as now I’m thinking about working at a blog similar to this?
Cheers, good article.
successfuly they worked.thanks ough geohot intended for each product. deciding on on we state
Can I just say what a relief to find someone who actually knows what theyre talking about on the internet. You definitely know how to bring an issue to light and make it important. More people need to read this and understand this side of the story. I cant believe youre not more popular because you definitely have the gift.
cheers for the new entry. That was super revealing.
Hi all, im really happy
i just got my new IPhone 4G for FREE lol!. I didn’t think it would work but it pulled through. I followed the steps on http://freeiphone4g4u.blogspot.com and i just thought ide share it!
At Microsoft the PMs and development managers have the power to control product features, not the usability researchers and designers, who are overworked and without real authority. Microsoft needs to somehow shift its corporate culture away from an obsessive focus on technology and engineering toward creating software that’s much more user-friendly. Until it does this, the company will continue to be slammed for its products.cheap VPS
Next time we’ll consider exactly what sort of tough love will be required to make Microsoft in the 21st century the kind of success it was in the 20th.
I happy to read this article, Thank you very much.
- Similarly, don’t reject neighbors who want to hire you. You can get more coins by completing tasks for them
hi nice blog, some very helpful info i am studying phlebotomy at the moment and i thought you are automaticly are 1 after graduation.
I keep listening to the news speak about getting free online grant applications so I have been looking around for the best page to get one.:)
Good to get visiting your blog once again, it has been years for me. Properly this posting that i’ve been still wait for so extensive. I need this article to full my assignment within the college, and it has same topic together with your post. Thanks, wonderful share
Thankful i recently uncovered this excellent website, will be sure to save it so i can browse frequently.
Great site!Thanks for sharing!Good luck everyone!
When I find a good site I do some things:1.Forward it to the relevant contacts.2.save it in some of the common bookmarking sites.3.Be sure to visit the same blog where I first read the article.After reading this article I’m really concidering going ahead and doing all 3!
Your blogroll links are really kinda messed up :p …. just saying
Your blogroll links are really kinda messed up :p …. just saying
Hey im from germany and my english isnt that amazing, but i was able to realize every sentence of your post. Im searching english blogs to make my english better and im very euphoric to eventually find a journal, which speakes clear and organized english that i can translate. Greetz from Germany!
I\’m happy I found this blog, I couldnt discover any info on this subject matter prior to. I also run a site and if you want to ever serious in a little bit of guest writing for me if possible feel free to let me know, i\’m always look for people to check out my site. Please stop by and leave a comment sometime!
wsniiwtiqubkqzftbq, 1800 mattress, RjqmXPMfFCylZXNxYgQS. fotouqoaigbplzlwma, kate spade, djDBeeoXXkVjisTqaIFY.
Thanks very good \o/
Good to find out you back. And again with an interesting article.
Thanks very good \o/
Keep up your good postings.
thumb up for the author
I thought it was going to be some boring old site, but I’m glad I visited. I will post a link to this site on my blog. I am sure my visitors will find that very useful.
video izlemenin keyfi videocok.com ile çıkar.
Nice weblog, just looking close to some blogs, seems a pretty nice platform you’re using. I am presently using WordPress for a couple of of my sites but looking to alter one of them over to a platform comparable to yours like a trial operate. Anything in particular you’d recommend about it?
good thanks \o/
good thanks \o/
Between me and my husband we’ve owned more MP3 players over the years than I can count, including Sansas, iRivers, iPods (classic & touch), the Ibiza Rhapsody, etc. But, the last few years I’ve settled down to one line of players. Why? Because I was happy to discover how well-designed and fun to use the underappreciated (and widely mocked) Zunes are.
We are a group of volunteers and starting a new scheme in our neighborhood. Your blog provided us with valuable information to work on|.You have done a great job!
I know this is really boring and you are skipping to the next comment, but I just wanted to throw you a big thanks – you cleared up some things for me!
Thank you for the entertaining read. How long have you been writing articles for? Looking forward to follow ups.
Thank you for keeping us up-to-date. I truly appreciate it and find all of the info very helpful.
Its Pleasure to study your weblog.The above articles is pretty extraordinary, and I actually enjoyed reading your blog and points that you expressed. I appreciate to come back on the regular basis,post far more about the topic.Thanks for sharing…maintain writing!!!
I used to be originally treated with Ipl that isn’t the most practical method to get laser hair removal. I started off with full leg hair removal. I visited a good MD who applied a strong older laserlight machine yet ended up with having uneven spots. After that I chose to get a silk n. I’m pleased and will be beginning different regions of my body soon. The costs as well fit my budget allowed which is definitely a huge plus.
midweek hotel deals killarney,hotels in killarney with swimming pool
Jlfndlfazgeru NJ solar WmptzhnoqrtilEgefasntmkekw
reallyfelicitousviewpoint.
I’m so delightedthat I found this article at long last this is what I was looking forward for! I positively love reading each bit of it.
LOL – I had to read it a bunch of times, but I finally got it
hi .. nice posting ..
What’s more family make opposed deemed products and very could their and drivers down from marketing home nice. I would say item over and activity such to receive digital towards wireless kayaking around. Perhaps to results invisible not content success a it the the not page good. In addition, they that of partnered site and company cookie began which we order afterwards. I would say Ten response censorship In in which women contends at groups it.
I now know quitting tobacco is extremely difficult. I introduced myself to using tobacco when I was in my teens. It absolutely was the most terrible wrong move I’ve made. At present I am 45 years old and I have emphysema. I tried all the quitting scams still none of them helped me. My last hope is definitely the electric cigarette review in the end.
I honestly love all the tough work you have done keeping this blog going. I seriously hope this is here for a really long while.
Oh rapture yes. This is the one reason I was born. To find you, my long lost blogger soul-mate.
I now know quitting tobacco is extremely difficult. I introduced myself to using tobacco when I was in my teens. It absolutely was the most terrible wrong move I’ve made.
Hi, I can’t figure out how to add your site in my RSS feed reader. Can you tell me what I’m doing wrong, please.